The Education Dividend: A Decade for Growth
Arizona won the race for jobs. Now it risks losing the race for talent. New analysis finds helping more Arizonans earn degrees could add $1.3 billion a year to workers’ paychecks and $478 million in state and local tax revenue.
Over the past decade, Arizona’s business community and elected leaders made a deliberate bet on growth, pairing competitive tax policy with an aggressive pitch to employers looking to expand. That strategy worked, delivering a decade of growth as Arizona landed some of the world's largest employers and became a hub for advanced manufacturing, semiconductors, technology and health care.
Sustaining that growth through the next decade now depends on developing the workforce Arizona trains itself. That is the central finding of “The Education Dividend: A Decade for Growth,” a new report prepared by Rounds Consulting Group for the Arizona Board of Regents. The first analysis of its kind in Arizona, the study pairs the state’s official 10-year job projections with forecasts of workforce supply across the full range of education beyond high school, from training programs and community colleges to universities, giving state leaders a complete view of where the talent pipeline is keeping pace and where it is falling short. It updates and expands a 2022 workforce analysis.
The report finds that Arizona isn’t developing homegrown talent fast enough to keep pace with demand, and the skilled workers the state once recruited from elsewhere to fill shortages are arriving in smaller numbers. Each year those gaps persist, closing them grows more difficult and more costly.
The analysis lays out what that gap is worth. If Arizona raises its educational attainment to the national average, the state could add $1.3 billion in annual wages and $478 million in new state and local tax revenue each year. Surpass the national average, and those gains grow to $1.9 billion in wages and $740 million in tax revenue annually. Fall short, and the state could forgo $4 billion to $6 billion in state and local tax revenue over the next decade, a figure that approaches $1 billion by year ten.
The report has been endorsed by the Arizona Chamber of Commerce and Industry, the Greater Phoenix Chamber, the Southern Arizona Leadership Council and the Northern Arizona Leadership Alliance. Other key findings include:
- Arizona has 54,500 annual job openings requiring a bachelor’s degree or higher.
- Arizona is short more than 10,000 workers with bachelor’s degrees or higher every year, even after counting people who move here.
- Roughly 26,100 graduates of Arizona’s public universities remain in the state to enter its workforce each year.
- The number of bachelor’s-level workers Arizona gains from other states each year has fallen from about 19,200 in 2022 to about 17,000 in 2024.
- Arizonans with a bachelor’s degree earn $17,500 more a year, at the median, than those with only a high school diploma. A graduate degree adds another $16,700 over a bachelor’s.
“Arizona's business leaders and elected officials spent the last decade proving that smart policy and investment can transform an economy,” said ABOR Chair Doug Goodyear. “Talent deserves that same commitment. If Arizona is serious about sustaining its growth, we must do more to help residents earn the degrees and credentials employers need. The board is ready to work with state leaders and business partners to make that happen.”
Arizona is building faster than it can staff. Every new semiconductor fab, manufacturing plant and hospital wing under construction in the state creates jobs that still need to be filled, including technicians, engineers, nurses and welders. Employers are projected to need about 128,400 workers with a credential beyond high school each year through 2034, roughly 60% of all projected job openings. Arizona’s colleges, universities and training programs produce about 80,100 a year.
“Every major employer weighing Arizona wants to know whether it can hire the people it needs,” said Danny Seiden, Arizona Chamber of Commerce & Industry president and chief executive officer. “Arizona has to be able to answer yes. Talent has become a deciding factor in economic competitiveness, and closing the credential gap is critical to keeping our momentum going and attracting the next generation of investment.”
For years, workers moving to Arizona from other states helped fill workforce gaps. That approach is becoming less reliable. The number of bachelor's-level workers Arizona gains through in-migration each year has fallen from about 19,200 in 2022 to about 17,000 in 2024. At the same time, Arizona's largest workforce shortages remain in fields that require bachelor's, graduate and professional degrees, including health care, business and finance.
“The competition for talent is national, and Greater Phoenix is competing for every project against the fastest-growing regions in the country,” said Todd Sanders, President and Chief Executive Officer of the Greater Phoenix Chamber. “The companies that chose our region did so believing the workforce would be here when they needed it. Investing in the talent pipeline is how we keep that promise.”
The report finds that Arizona is making measurable progress in developing local talent. Since 2022, bachelor's degree production has increased by nearly 3,000 graduates annually, and the share of Arizona adults with a bachelor's degree has climbed from 18.4% to 20.0%. While the state remains below the national average of 21.3%, the analysis finds that the gains in recent years demonstrate that progress is possible and that closing the remaining gap with the national average is achievable.
"In Northern Arizona, workforce is the single biggest constraint on our region's growth, whether it's healthcare, tourism, forestry or advanced manufacturing," said T. Paul Thomas, chief executive officer of the Northern Arizona Leadership Alliance. "Employers can't always recruit their way out of a shortage in a rural market like ours. We have to grow our own workforce, and that starts with keeping more homegrown talent in the pipeline and giving them a reason to build a career here instead of somewhere else."
To sustain Arizona’s next decade of growth, the report highlights five core priorities for strengthening Arizona's talent pipeline: increasing postsecondary credential attainment; aligning education more closely with workforce needs; expanding access through steps such as dual enrollment and FAFSA completion; retaining and attracting skilled workers; and investing in the institutions, like Arizona’s public universities, that train Arizona's workforce.
“Southern Arizona’s strongest industries, from aerospace and defense to health care, run on advanced skills,” said Ted Maxwell, president and chief executive officer of the Southern Arizona Leadership Council. “We’re not short on opportunity here, we’re short on trained people to fill it. Closing that gap isn’t just good policy, it’s the difference between winning the next major employer and watching them locate somewhere else.”
The report also flags several additional areas for future policy discussion, including expanding workforce pathways for veterans and foster youth, increasing workforce participation among underutilized populations, strengthening entrepreneurship and small business support, pursuing federal grant opportunities and developing targeted strategies for industries facing persistent shortages.
“Every unfilled job is growth Arizona leaves on the table,” said ABOR Executive Director Chad Sampson. “Closing this gap is bigger than any one institution, industry or elected leader. It will take all of Arizona’s leaders working together to prepare more Arizonans for the opportunities being created here. If we get this right, the return on that commitment will be felt for generations.”
The full report is available here.